Jay County, IN Property Tax: $665/yr (2026)
Last reviewed:
The effective property tax rate in Jay County is 0.60% of assessed home value. On a home at the county median value of $110,100, that works out to about $661 per year, or $55 per month. Jay County is located in eastern Indiana, and is home to approximately 20,281 residents.
About Jay County
Jay County covers approximately 383.9 square miles in Indiana. The county is home to about 20,281 residents living in roughly 8,908 housing units, of which 69.7% are owner-occupied. The median household income is $54,114, and the median home was built in 1958.
Jay County borders Adams County, Blackford County, Delaware County, Randolph County, Wells County — useful comparisons if you're considering nearby areas with potentially different tax rates.
How Property Taxes Work in Indiana
Property taxes in Indiana are administered at the county level. Each county sets a millage rate applied to the assessed value of real property — the effective rate above accounts for any partial assessments and exemptions already built into the local tax base. Assessed value can differ meaningfully from current market value depending on how often the county reassesses and what fraction of market value it uses.
Most counties in Indiana offer exemptions that reduce the taxable assessed value: homestead exemptions for primary residences, senior exemptions, disability exemptions, and veteran exemptions are common. These reduce your effective rate below the county-wide average shown here. Contact the Jay County Assessor's office to learn which exemptions apply to your property and when to file.
Jay County vs. Neighboring Counties
| Location | Eff. Rate | Median Home | Annual Tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jay County, IN | 0.60% | $110,100 | $661 |
| Indiana state average | 0.67% | — | $738* |
| Adams County | 0.75% | $173,100 | $1,295 |
| Blackford County | 0.81% | $96,700 | $779 |
| Delaware County | 0.78% | $127,600 | $997 |
| Randolph County | 0.83% | $106,000 | $881 |
| Wells County | 0.51% | $180,000 | $920 |
| US national average | 1.10% | $281,900 | $3,101 |
*State average annual tax computed at Jay County's median home value of $110,100. Source: US Census ACS 2023 5-year estimates.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Jay County's property tax rate compare to the rest of Indiana?
At 0.60%, Jay County is lower than the Indiana state average of 0.67%. On a home at the county median of $110,100, that means about $661 per year — versus $738 at the state average rate, a difference of $77 per year. Compared to the national average of 1.10%, Jay County is below average.
What's a typical annual property tax bill in Jay County?
For a home at the county median value of $110,100, the annual property tax in Jay County is approximately $661 — or about $55 per month. For a home worth $165,150, expect around $991 per year. For a $220,200 home, approximately $1,321 per year. Use the calculator above to estimate taxes for any assessed value.
Where do I appeal a Jay County property tax assessment?
Property assessment appeals in Jay County are handled by the Jay County Assessor's office. Most jurisdictions require filing within 30–90 days of receiving your assessment notice — confirm the specific deadline with the assessor's office before submitting, as deadlines and procedures vary by county. A successful appeal can reduce your assessed value and lower your tax bill for the current and future tax years.
What exemptions are available in Jay County?
Indiana counties commonly offer homestead exemptions for owner-occupied primary residences, senior citizen exemptions for qualifying homeowners aged 65 and older, exemptions for disabled residents, and veterans' exemptions. Each exemption reduces your assessed taxable value, which in turn reduces your effective tax rate below the county-wide 0.60% shown here. Contact the Jay County Assessor's office to confirm which exemptions are available and the application deadlines.
Data sources: US Census Bureau ACS 2023 5-Year Estimates, US Census Gazetteer (2024), County Adjacency File